Category Archives: Ghana

An Apples-to-Apples Comparison of African Sovereign Debt

I’ve been meaning to do this for months now, and the FT’s Jonathan Wheatley has just done it for me. Herewith, a side-by-side comparison of 10-year African sovereign debt issues from the past 15 months:

Country Issue Date Tenor Size Yield at issue
Zambia Sep 2012 10 years $750 mm 5.625%
Rwanda Apr 2013 10 years $400 mm 6.875%
Nigeria July 2013 10 years $500 mm 6.625%
Ghana July 2013 10 years $750 mm 8.000%
Gabon Dec 2013 10 years $1.5 bn 6.375%

As Wheatley correctly points out, this is a Gabon story as much as it’s an Africa story. There are a lot of ways to slice this, the most immediate being yield differences. Wheatley:

Is Zambia, at 5.625 per cent (cheaper than Spain at the time), really in a different ball park from Ghana at 8 per cent? Yes and no. When Zambia came to market in September 2012, yields on US Treasuries were at their tightest and investors were scrambling for any deal that offered something better.

“There were opportunities to lock in great transactions,” says Samara. “But you still had to have a story to tell.”

Rwanda faced perhaps an even more inviting market, with investors getting so frustrated at low yields in the US they seemed willing to take almost any risk. Even in that environment, however, Rwanda had to pay a lot more than Zambia.

Nigeria and Ghana tell a similar tale of the post-tapering world: the decidedly less risk-on environment that followed comments in May by Ben Bernanke, chairman of the US Federal Reserve, suggesting the end of ultra-loose monetary policy was on the horizon. But Samara says that even in those more difficult circumstances, the right issuers have been able to get bonds away.

I would also point out the dramatic difference between these yields, and the indicative yields of their currencies at the beginning of this year, which I previously discussed here. Pasting those local currency yields into the above table gives us the following:

 

Country Issue Date Tenor Size Yield at issue Indicative FX yield as of Jan 2013
Zambia Sep 2012 10 years $750 mm 5.625% 9.80%
Rwanda Apr 2013 10 years $400 mm 6.875% 12.30%
Nigeria July 2013 10 years $500 mm 6.625% 14.40%
Ghana July 2013 10 years $750 mm 8.000% 22.90%
Gabon Dec 2013 10 years $1.5 bn 6.375% N/A

 

The debt yields are significantly lower than the FX yields reported in January (courtesy of Silk Invest). A lot has happened in the world this year to drive this divergence, but what this screams of more than anything to me is the benefit of borrowing dollars in the Eurobond market. 

Put another way, let’s use the example of Nigeria, which is far and away the largest economy of any of these. In an ideal world, an economy like Nigeria should be able to draw a far larger issue size than $500 million, and denominated in naira, but if they did, they would be paying much more than 6.625%. And even in dollars, the $500 million ticket size indicates that appetite is still fairly limited, despite all the currency risk being shifted onto Nigeria (which, having some 90+% of its economy dependent on oil, is less burdensome than the task facing, say, Rwanda).

I’m all for developing local currency financing mechanisms, but what this all says to me is that there’s still a VERY long way to go.

Making Sense Of Angola Stock Exchange Plans

Africa Stock Market Cap FiguresBloomberg had a story out late last week about plans for an Angola Stock Exchange, entitled, “Angola Plans 6th-Biggest Africa Bourse With Value at 10% of GDP”. Since we (and by we, I mean you and me, in an apparently small minority) are resolved to have a realistic approach in discussing economic prospects anywhere, here are the main points of interest from the article once we strip away all the spin and optimism:

  • Angola, Africa’s second-biggest oil producer, expects its stock exchange to have a market value of 10 percent of gross domestic product within 18 months of its startup, making it at least the continent’s sixth biggest.
  • The capitalization of the exchange, set to start in 2015, would be a minimum of $11 billion based on last year’s output of $114 billion.
  • The Angolan government is forecasting economic growth of 7.1 percent this year, down from 7.4 percent in 2012.
  • A secondary bond market will start this year to help develop a yield curve.
  • South Africa’s bourse is the continent’s largest at $842 billion, more than double its GDP.
  • Angola ranks 157th out of 176 countries on Transparency International’s 2012 Corruption Perceptions Index.

The investment bank Imara just put together this brief which summarizes some key data points for other stock markets in Africa. There’s some good trading info in there but missing is any indication of market capitalization figures. I should add that this isn’t Imara’s fault necessarily as this data is generally pretty hard to come by.

The thing is, this isn’t the first time Angola has made efforts at opening a stock exchange. In December 2007, allAfrica.com ran a story entitled, “Angola: Stock Exchange Opens in 2008”, but I definitely remember hearing about this before then, though not as far back as 2003, which is when this article dates the beginning of the process.

In any event, here’s a more “recent” take on the Angola stock exchange prediction, from How We Made It In Africa in 2010. Apparently, Angola’s planned exchange was then expected to be the third largest in Africa. Particularly striking from the 2010 article was this little snippet:
Continue reading

Chart of the Day: Sub-Saharan Africa’s Mobile Phone Market

Lots of room to run here. What this doesn’t give us a clear view of though is undersubscription relative to absolute market size. Nigeria would obviously be the winner on that front.

2013.03.18.Sub-Saharan Africa Mobile

How Oil Divides The Economies Of Africa Into Winners And Losers

I can’t get this article from the FT’s William Wallis out of my head. The headline is “Currencies pressed by trade imbalances” but this really only captures a small slice of the picture. Check it out:

With import demand outstripping export growth in some of the continent’s fastest expanding economies, rising trade imbalances are putting pressure on currencies. African and international investors hedge against this by spreading risk – one factor that is driving African banks and businesses across borders.

But even an expansive footprint is not always enough. MTN, the continent’s leading telecoms provider with a presence in 21 African countries, announced that currency swings had weighed heavily on its earnings.

More broadly says Razia Khan, head of Africa research at Standard Chartered Bank, widening current account deficits are the result of an investment and consumption boom, new resource exploration activity and “the scaling up of output”. Ghana fits into this category. It is also on the risk radar this year as heavy investment in oil and gas infrastructure continues, with only modest increases forecast for oil output.

A weak currency does not help those African countries with limited capacity to ramp up exports in response. Kenya cannot for example suddenly double tea production. So, it is forced to defend its currency to avert importing inflation.

Loose monetary policy in major developed economies has driven a rush of short-term funds into African markets. David Cowan, Africa economist at Citibank, says the way in which central banks defend their currencies and the margins that foreign investors earn will be one determining factor in how long the appetite endures.

I don’t disagree with any of this but would point out that this is all just the tip of the iceberg and there are a lot of ways to slice this.

One is that just six of Africa’s 53 countries account for two-thirds of the entirety of Africa’s $2.0 trillion economy. In descending order of nominal GDP: South Africa, Nigeria, Egypt, Algeria, Angola and Morocco. I think a pie chart best demonstrates this relationship:

2013.03.20.Africa 2013 GDP composition

Another is to think about how much of Africa’s total economy is driven by oil exports. Let’s try the following table to demonstrate this:

Continue reading

Chart of the Day: Frontier Markets Fixed Income Yields

We would be wise remind ourselves first of the definition of the impossible trinity: it is impossible to have (a) a fixed exchange rate, (b) absence of capital controls and (c) an independent monetary policy.

Remember that. I’m going to come back to that.

So Silk Invest has this going on:

“The chart on the right hand side compares currencies in terms of Purchasing Power Parity. What the graph tells us is that the adjusted value of the Brazilian Real is similar to the US$, while most frontier market currencies are systematically undervalued.”

2013.01.23.Frontier Markets yields

The problem I’ve always had with Purchasing Power Parity is that it assumes equivalent standards of living across markets when in fact that is very rarely the case. Put another way, a dollar may buy more in Brazil than in Vietnam, but this says nothing about what the average citizen in either of those countries needs to sustain a living.

But that’s an argument for another time and another context. Otherwise, this is a very compelling chart. A couple things off the top of my head:

Continue reading

“Zambia is an Argentina without a Christina Kirchner”

Everything here I consider of equal importance but the fact of how we digest information is that something must come first. So let’s start with that headline quote, which came from Michael Power of Investec Asset Management in this 12 minute interview. Lest you don’t have 12 minutes to watch it (which is what I’m here for), the short version of what Mr. Power has to say is that Investec rejects the broad categorization wrought by the terms “emerging markets” and “frontier markets” for something Investec has taken to calling “horizon markets”.

Yes, you read that correctly. Pardon me if I’m late to this party, but this is the first I’ve heard of this. Horizon markets apparently includes “second tier” emerging markets, which consists of a handful of countries less prominent than the BRICS but with investable entry and exit points far ahead of any failed state. Here’s a chart Investec included in London-based Clear Path Analysis’ recently released overview of Frontier Markets investing:

Also noteworthy from the video interview, Investec likes the following when it comes to investing in Africa:
Continue reading

How political risk translates into Ghana’s foreign direct investment prospects

Renaissance Capital’s Yvonne Mhango breaks down possible paths for the future of Ghana’s political leadership and what each means for the country’s FDI prospects:

On the whole, the ruling NDC is considered to be a social democrat government that is more likely to retain subsidies (such as on fuel), refrain from privatisation and raise taxes, as it did earlier this year on the mining companies. There is a low risk of the legislation and tax regime for energy and mining being changed because the party more likely to do so, the NDC, has already done it; and the business-friendly NPP would be unlikely to do so. The NDC government has already increased the tax burden on mining companies by 10 percentage points to 35 per cent and imposed a 10 per cent windfall profit tax on all mining companies.
Continue reading

What Higher Oil Prices Mean for Sub-Saharan Africa

I just finished reading Alterio Research’s new Frontier Africa report, “Surging oil prices – gift or curse?” which frankly could quite easily be renamed, “Dutch Disease by any other name”. The report (available for free here) attempts to measure the impact of rising oil prices on inflation, fiscal stability and economic growth on the following countries: Angola, Botswana, Ghana, Kenya, Namibia, Nigeria, Tanzania and Zambia.

The essential takeaways here that I see are the following:
Continue reading